Quest For Answers

Using Medical Illustrations to Persuade in an Spine Injury Trial

Written by

admin_troy

in

Using Medical Illustrations to Persuade in an Injury Trial

Medical illustrations are invaluable in a personal injury trial involving complex spine surgeries. They translate technical procedures – like a cervical disc replacement and an laminotomy/foraminotomy with microdiscectomy – into visuals a jury can grasp. Effective illustrations not only educate (showing what was injured and how it was fixed) but also evoke empathy by highlighting the ordeal your client endured. Below, we discuss professional illustration services, DIY software options, combining graphics with real patient scans, and best practices for presenting these visuals (print and digital) in court.

Professional Medical Illustration Services

Hiring a professional medical illustrator or litigation graphics firm is the most reliable way to get high-quality, accurate visuals. Specialized companies like MediVisuals, Artery Studios, Medical Visions, Inc., and others have extensive experience producing trial exhibits for personal injury and medical malpractice cases​

medicalvisions.com​

nlva.law. These services create case-specific illustrations using your client’s actual medical records – operative reports, imaging, doctor descriptions – to ensure accuracy​

  • What They Provide: Skilled artists can depict the affected anatomy (e.g. the cervical spine at C6-C7 or lumbar spine at L3-L4) and the surgical steps undertaken. For example, they might illustrate how the surgeon removed a damaged disc and inserted an artificial implant at C6-C7, or how a microdiscectomy at L3-L5 involved cutting away part of the lamina (laminotomy) and removing disc material pressing on nerves (foraminotomy/discectomy). These illustrations often include cut-away views of the spine, surgical instruments, implants (screws, artificial disc device), and even insets showing before-and-after conditions. The goal is to accurately and dramatically represent the unique injury your client sustained​arterystudios.com.
  • Emotional Impact: Professional illustrators know how to strike the right balance between medical accuracy and emotional resonance. They use color and detail to highlight trauma – for instance, showing angry red nerve roots being compressed by a herniated disc, or the metallic hardware now permanently in the neck. As Bob Shepherd (veteran medical illustrator) notes, a surgery itself is “a second traumatic event” for the body, and a good illustration emphasizes “how it gets in there” – the cutting of soft tissues, insertion of screws, etc. – so jurors appreciate the true invasiveness of the procedure ​ckflaw.com​ckflaw.com. These visuals can convey pain and suffering in a way words alone cannot, without being gory or off-putting (firms deliberately avoid overly bloody depictions so as not to alienate the jury ​medicalvisions.com).
  • Combining with Medical Data: Top illustration firms will often incorporate elements of the patient’s actual scans for credibility. For example, Artery Studios’ president Stephen Mader describes taking a client’s CT/MRI and building a 3D model or illustration from it, so that laypeople can readily appreciate the trauma on the scan​ ckflaw.com​ ckflaw.com. This means the final artwork isn’t a generic spine – it’s literally based on the client’s films, lending authenticity. (More on combining with imaging in a section below.)
  • Cost: Prices vary with complexity and provider. As a rough guide, custom medical-legal illustrations often cost on the order of $500 to $1,500 each. One law firm notes “one medical illustration can cost $1,000” in case expenses​ cochranfirm.com. Another trial consultant advises that effective illustrations can be had for under $500 in simpler cases ​focusgraphics.com. In general, a straightforward single-panel illustration (e.g. a single view of the cervical spine highlighting a disc injury) might be at the lower end (a few hundred dollars), whereas a multi-step surgical storyboard or highly detailed color render could approach $1,000 or more. (For reference, medical illustrators often charge hourly – e.g. ~$100–$150/hour – and a full-color illustration might take 15+ hours.) Animations are much pricier (often $5,000–$10,000 for a short 3D surgical animation​cochranfirm.com), so sticking to still illustrations is more cost-effective for most cases.
  • Turnaround Time: Expect roughly 2–3 weeks for a custom illustration in non-rush situations ​lindsaymedart.com ​totaltrialsolutions.com. This typically includes initial sketches, one or two revision rounds, and final art. Many firms offer expedited service (sometimes even a few days turnaround) for an extra fee or for simpler jobs. It’s wise to contact the illustrator well in advance of trial – not only to buffer time for revisions, but also because their production schedules fill up. (Some studios schedule cases 6–8 weeks out, except for rush jobs.) Be prepared to provide all relevant medical records upfront and to have your medical expert review drafts for accuracy.
  • Output Formats: Professional services will deliver high-resolution digital images (suitable for large prints or projection). For instance, MediVisuals often provides 30” x 40” poster-size exhibits on foam board for use in court​medivisuals1.com​medivisuals1.com, and a digital version for presentations. You can typically request printed trial boards directly through the service or get the files to print yourself. Most illustrations are in full color and can be printed on poster paper, laminated, or mounted, as well as inserted into slide decks for digital display.
  • Notable Providers: MediVisuals (long-standing U.S. firm with a large stock library and custom work), Artery Studios (known for vivid illustrations and animations, based in Canada but serves U.S. trials​ckflaw.com), Medical Visions, Inc. (emphasizes lower pricing and fast turnaround​medicalvisions.com), Anatomical Justice, High Impact Graphics, and boutique illustrators like Lindsay Illustrations or Wayne Heim. Many of these have online galleries where you can see examples of spine surgery exhibits. For instance, Medical Visions highlights its “clear, concise, & educational style” that avoids over-the-top gore​medicalvisions.com, and its use of experience from thousands of exhibits over 25+ years​medicalvisions.com.

DIY Options and Illustration Software

If budget constraints prevent hiring a professional, or if you want to prepare some visuals in-house, there are software tools and resources to create medical illustrations and exhibits yourself. While DIY requires more effort and won’t match a seasoned medical artist’s polish, it can still yield effective results especially for simpler graphics or combining existing images.

  • DICOM Viewers for 3D Reconstructions: One of the best DIY approaches is leveraging your client’s actual medical imaging (MRI, CT scans) to generate visuals. Free or low-cost DICOM viewer software like OsiriX/Horos (Mac) or RadiAnt/ONIS (PC) can load the scan data and create high-quality 3D reconstructions of the spine​ medmovie.com. For example, you could take the CT of the cervical spine post-disc-replacement and reconstruct a 3D model that shows an artificial disc device in place, or use an MRI to 3D-render the herniated disc fragment. Even the free versions of these programs often have all the functionality needed (the paid versions ~$400–$700 offer advanced features but are not always necessary)​medmovie.com. You can then snapshot images or video of these reconstructions. This technique ensures accuracy because it’s literally your client’s anatomy on display – and you can rotate it or isolate structures to make the injury clear ​medmovie.com​ medmovie.com.
  • Anatomy Illustration and 3D Apps: There are several applications with pre-built anatomical models that you can manipulate without deep art skills. 3D anatomy apps like Complete Anatomy (3D4Medical) or Visible Body allow you to zoom in on specific vertebrae, discs, nerves, etc., remove layers of muscle, and add labels. For instance, you could use such an app to show a close-up of the C6-C7 motion segment and demonstrate where the disc was replaced (and even import a 3D model of an artificial disc implant if available). BioDigital Human (a web-based 3D anatomy tool) is another option to visually explore and capture views of the spine. These apps usually cost a few hundred dollars or less (some are subscription-based ~$20–$50/month). After creating the view you want, you’d export an image and then possibly annotate it with arrows/text in an image editor or presentation software.
  • Graphic Design Software: If you have some art or design capability, using tools like Adobe Photoshop or Illustrator can let you create custom graphics. For example, you might trace over an MRI to highlight a herniated disc in color, or draw a schematic of the disc replacement procedure. Even PowerPoint or Keynote can be surprisingly useful for basic illustration: you can overlay shapes and callouts on top of medical images (like drawing a colored diagram of a spine next to an X-ray). There are also libraries of pre-made medical clip art or vector drawings – though spine surgery specifics are harder to find in generic clip art, you might find pieces (vertebra shapes, etc.) to assemble a graphic.
  • Stock Medical Illustrations and Templates: A middle-ground between DIY and fully custom art is to purchase or license stock medical illustrations. Many illustration companies offer pre-drawn graphics of common injuries and surgeries at lower cost. For instance, MediVisuals sells stock exhibits (some spinal injury boards are listed around $395–$590 each​medivisuals1.com), and Ion Medical Designs’ catalog shows items like an L5-S1 Microdiscectomy illustration for $400 (in stock) and a Cervical Spine Fusion for $500. Trial Guides (a publisher for plaintiff attorneys) even offers a “High Impact Graphics Collection” – a curated library of 100+ medical illustrations covering common injuries, ready to download for use in demand packages or trial ​trialguides.com. You might find a generic C6-7 disc replacement illustration or a lumbar discectomy illustration that, with a bit of tweaking, fits your case. While these won’t show your client’s exact anatomy, they can be persuasive visuals if the injury and procedure are fairly typical. Always ensure you have the proper license for use in court. Most stock illustrations can be integrated into your exhibits and annotated as needed.
  • Integration and Editing: With any of these DIY tools, plan to combine elements. For example, you might export a 3D spine image from OsiriX, then open it in Photoshop to add a color highlight on the damaged disc and an arrow labeling “Herniated disc compressing nerve.” Or take a stock cervical surgery graphic and overlay an actual post-op X-ray in the corner. The key is clarity and accuracy. If you lack confidence in medical details, collaborate with the treating physician to verify you’re marking the right anatomy. If you label a diagram, always double-check everything is correctly labeled – small errors can undermine credibility.
  • Cost and Time for DIY: The software costs range from free (for basic DICOM viewers) up to a few hundred dollars (for advanced apps or Adobe subscriptions). Stock images might cost a few hundred each. The real investment is time and skill – expect to spend hours learning the software and refining the images. If trial is near, weigh whether that time is better spent preparing other aspects versus hiring a pro. One advantage of DIY or stock solutions is immediacy – you can obtain images quickly (sometimes instantly via download) rather than waiting weeks. This can help in last-minute situations, like needing a visual for a mediation brief or if a budget for demonstratives wasn’t approved until late.

Combining Illustrations with Actual Patient Imaging

For maximum impact and credibility, combine illustrative graphics with your client’s actual MRI, X-ray, or CT images. Jurors tend to find medical scans convincing (“hard evidence”), yet most laypeople struggle to interpret them​

totaltrialsolutions.com. By blending the two – the real film and an artist’s depiction – you get the best of both worlds: authenticity and clarity.

  • Colorized Films: One effective technique is to colorize the original radiology images. Instead of showing the jury a fuzzy black-and-white MRI and expecting them to spot the disc herniation, you can add color to highlight key structures. For example, keep the bony vertebrae in grayscale but color the herniated disc material bright red and the affected nerve yellow. Services exist that do this, or it can be done in Photoshop. According to litigation consultants, “Colorized MRI films can distinctly show the detail of a client’s soft tissue injuries… and provide an instant visualization of the seriousness of the injuries.”​ totaltrialsolutions.com Jurors no longer have to squint at a film – the injury is literally highlighted for them.
  • X-rays with Hardware: After a C6-C7 disc replacement, your client likely has an X-ray or fluoroscopic image showing the artificial disc device in their neck. Consider enlarging that X-ray and adding color to differentiate components (metal implant vs bone vs soft tissue)​ totaltrialsolutions.com. A consultant from Total Trial Solutions notes that colorizing post-op X-rays (e.g. tinting the screws and plates a metallic blue or gray while bone remains off-white) “brings it to life and usually invokes a reaction of ‘ouch, glad that’s not me.’”​ totaltrialsolutions.com This kind of visceral reaction is exactly what you want jurors to feel – it helps them empathize with the pain and difficulty your client endured. Showing before-and-after images side by side works well: e.g. a pre-surgery X-ray or MRI with a big red bulging disc, and a post-surgery X-ray with rods/plates/screws colored in. The contrast visually tells the story of an injury and the drastic fix required.

ckflaw.com​

totaltrialsolutions.com.

  • Illustration Overlays: Another approach is a transparent overlay or side-by-side pairing. An illustrator can create an image that maps onto the scan – for instance, drawing the outline of thecal sac and nerves on top of an MRI slice, or indicating where the surgeon cut bone on a CT cross-section. “Radiology paint-overs,” as some call them, use an opaque painted version of anatomy corresponding exactly to a given slice of imaging​lindsaymedart.com. You might see this as a ghosted illustration superimposed on the original film. Alternatively, present them adjacent: the left half of a board is the unmodified film with an arrow, the right half is a color diagram explaining that film. When jurors see them together, it clicks – they get what the scan shows ​ckflaw.com.
  • Use Patient’s Data to Drive the Art: When commissioning custom illustrations, provide the artist with copies of the actual MRIs and X-rays. They often will trace the important parts from the scans to ensure fidelity​ckflaw.com. The end product can even include a small copy of the original film on the exhibit for reference. This can be powerful in court: your medical expert can testify that “this illustration is a faithful representation of the injuries as seen on Mr. Smith’s MRI, just rendered in 3D for clarity.” The jury thus trusts the illustration as if it were evidence, not just artist imagination.
  • Accuracy and Admissibility: It’s crucial that any enhancement of imaging doesn’t distort the truth. Courts allow demonstratives that “assist the jury in understanding” the evidence as long as they are substantially like the real thing ​medimagery.com. Have the treating surgeon or radiologist review and confirm that the colored or combined images are accurate. That witness can then lay foundation, e.g. “I’ve compared this colored exhibit to the original MRI, and the red area here correctly shows the disc herniation at L3-4 as it appears on the film.” This foundation is usually required to admit the illustrative exhibit as a full exhibit (so the jury can even take it to deliberations) ​medimagery.com.

In practice, combining actual imaging with illustrations not only educates the jury but also adds persuasive weight. They see proof of injury with their own eyes, and they see an easy-to-understand depiction of its effect. It bridges the gap between cold medical data and human impact, which can be the difference in an emotional personal injury case.

Designing Illustrations to Resonate with a Jury

All the science and accuracy aside, remember that jurors are human. The illustrations should speak to their hearts as well as minds:

  • Show the Trauma: These surgeries are major events in your client’s life – portray them as such. For the a disc replacement, an illustration might show the surgical approach through the front of the neck, the removal of the damaged disc, and the insertion of the artificial disc device between two vertebrae. Emphasize what a drastic intrusion this is: retractors holding muscles aside, surgical tools in the spine, metal hardware now sitting where natural tissue used to be. One expert noted that without illustrating “how it gets in there” – the force, cutting, and disruption of surgery – the case might “fall short” of conveying its full impact​ckflaw.com. By visualizing the procedure, you turn an abstract “surgery” into a concrete injury of its own.
  • Convey Pain and Difficulty: In the a microdiscectomy illustration, you can communicate the relief and remaining pain. For instance, show in one image a cross-section of the spine with a large disc fragment compressing a nerve (perhaps the nerve drawn in an alarmed red color to signify pain). In the next image (post-surgery), show that fragment removed (a space where it was), with a surgical scar or a piece of bone missing from the laminotomy – indicating both that pressure is relieved and that the body has been permanently altered. Maybe include a small depiction of scar tissue forming or the healed incision site. The jurors subliminally think, “that must have hurt, and even fixing it caused trauma.”
  • Use Relatable Elements: Sometimes adding a familiar reference helps the jury connect. For example, an image of surgical hardware (screws, cages, rods) next to a ruler for scale can make jurors gasp when they realize a 2-inch screw was drilled into the spine. Or illustrate the range of motion lost vs. gained: perhaps a before/after of the neck bending, to show that the artificial disc preserves some motion (versus a fusion) – this could underscore that even with high-tech treatment, the spine will never be 100% normal.
  • Comparative Anatomy: As a visual strategy, consider including a normal-versus-injured comparison. One panel could depict a normal healthy cervical disc and nerve roots, and the adjacent panel shows the injured level with a collapsed disc or bone spurs indenting the nerve, plus the post-surgery state with the implant. Highlighting the difference can evoke jurors’ concern (“the poor plaintiff’s spine was in bad shape and had to be fixed with this device”). In fact, side-by-side healthy vs damaged illustrations are a common technique to drive home the extent of an injury​ckflaw.com.
  • Keep It Understandable: While detail is good, avoid cluttering the illustration with every minutiae of anatomy. The average juror won’t know Latin names of ligaments, and they don’t need an anatomy lesson on parts that aren’t at issue. Focus on the injury and repair. Use simple labels (“Herniated Disc,” “Nerve Root”, “Removed Bone”) and perhaps color-code them. A clear, uncluttered image will stick in memory longer than a complicated textbook figure. Medical Visions describes their artwork as “clear, concise, & educational… easy for a non-medical jury to understand”​medicalvisions.com – that’s a good mantra to follow.
  • Elicit Empathy, Not Disgust: We want the jury to feel the plaintiff’s pain, but not to feel sick. Avoid gratuitous gore – excessive blood, exposed flesh – unless absolutely necessary to show an injury. For spine surgeries, typically illustrators show a clean view of the vertebrae and disc (as if the area is surgically opened and clean). This is enough to convey the point. If you have actual surgery photos, you might decide not to show them and use an illustration instead, because real photos can be messy and upsetting. A well-done illustration can actually seem less graphic while still demonstrating the serious nature of the procedure (e.g. using moderated colors for tissue). This keeps jurors on your side. An illustration that’s too graphic could backfire if jurors look away or resent the perceived attempt to shock.

ckflaw.com​

medicalvisions.com.

  • Leverage “Storyboards”: As in the example above, showing a sequence can be powerful. Humans think in stories. Instead of just a single static image of the spine, a series of illustration panels telling the story of the injury and surgery can be incredibly compelling. For instance, one board could have three panels: “Injury” (C6-7 disc herniated in red, compressing spinal cord – maybe caused by a crash illustration), “Surgery” (surgeon removing disc and placing artificial disc implant), and “Aftermath” (the spine with the new implant in place and residual effects like a scar or stiffness). By visually walking them through it, you engage the jury’s emotions at each step – the shock of injury, the pain and drama of surgery, and the outcome your client must live with.

Presenting the Visuals: Print vs. Digital and Courtroom Tips

How you deliver these illustrations to the jury can influence their impact. Both printed exhibits and digital presentations have roles, and often a combination is ideal.

  • Large Print Boards: There’s a reason trial lawyers still use poster boards on easels – they are tangible and constantly visible. A large, printed board (e.g. 24”×36” or 30”×40”) of the key illustration can be placed in front of the jury during the treating doctor’s testimony and even left up during arguments (if allowed). Jurors can physically point to it during deliberations if it’s admitted as an exhibit. Make sure to print in high resolution on quality material (foam-core mounted prints are common). Matte finish is preferable to avoid glare from courtroom lights. If you have multiple boards (say one for each surgery), label them clearly (e.g. “Exhibit 5A: C6-7 Disc Replacement Surgery”) for easy reference.
  • Digital Slide Presentation: Using PowerPoint or other trial presentation software to show the illustrations on a screen can add flexibility. You can zoom in on parts of the illustration, highlight sections sequentially, or overlay animations (such as a fading between the before and after). For example, you might start by showing the pre-op MRI, then click to overlay the colorized version highlighting the herniation, then click to show the artist’s illustration of the surgical fix. This dynamic reveal can help keep jurors engaged. If you go digital, coordinate with courtroom technology – ensure there’s a projector or large monitors. Have someone tech-savvy to run the presentation (some firms provide a trial tech). Also, always have a backup plan: technology can fail, so have printed copies of crucial images on hand just in case.
  • Combining Approaches: Many attorneys use a hybrid strategy: use digital slides during testimony (for the step-by-step narration, zooming and such), and also introduce the static boards as evidence so they can be taken to the jury room. You might, for instance, use a short animation or 3D rotation during the doctor’s explanation of the cervical implant, but then submit a still illustration or series of stills that capture the same information. Judges vary on how much tech they allow jurors to use in deliberations, but a foam board doesn’t require any equipment and can be freely examined.
  • Highlighting and Interaction: During trial, make the illustrations interactive in the sense that the witness should use them as a teaching tool. A skilled orthopedic surgeon or neurosurgeon will “talk the jury through” the image: e.g. “Here you can see the C6-C7 level – this red area is the ruptured disc pressing on the spinal cord (pointing). In the next image, I’ve removed the disc and inserted the artificial disc device, shown in blue here.” This narration paired with the visual locks in understanding. Encourage the witness to physically get up and point at the board or use a laser pointer on the screen. This movement and focus directs jurors’ eyes to the important parts. Best practice is to rehearse this: ensure the witness is comfortable with the exhibit layout and doesn’t block the jury’s view.
  • Simplicity and Focus: When presenting, don’t overwhelm jurors by dumping a stack of diagrams on them all at once. Introduce each visual at the moment it becomes relevant in testimony. For example, when the surgeon describes the need for surgery, then reveal the illustration of the procedure. Too many visuals shown too early can confuse. It’s often effective to use one illustration at a time, or one board with a few panels, and have the witness explain it fully. You can always recap later by showing the illustration again during closing arguments to reinforce the key points.
  • Courtroom Admissibility: Typically, medical illustrations are used as demonstrative evidence – aids to explain witness testimony. They usually aren’t themselves “evidence” unless the court admits them. Make sure you disclose these exhibits to opposing counsel as required, and be prepared to have your expert witness authenticate them. The foundational questions are basically: Does this illustration fairly and accurately represent the condition/procedure? If the answer is yes, most judges will allow it (or at least let it be used demonstratively). Some judges will even mark it as an exhibit if properly sponsored, meaning it goes back with the jury. It’s smart to have a stipulation or motion in limine resolved beforehand if you anticipate objections. Emphasize that the illustration is based on the medical records and made under the expert’s guidance, not a piece of advocacy fiction​ckflaw.com. When done right, these visuals are seen as a true representation of the injuries​medimagery.com​medimagery.com, which hugely bolsters their persuasive power.
  • Printing and Cost for Presentation: Don’t forget to budget for printing and display materials. A professionally printed trial board can cost ~$100–$200 each (or more for very large or rush jobs). If you use a service like the illustration company or a local print shop, factor in turnaround time (usually a day or two for large prints). Ensure the images have sufficient resolution (usually 300 DPI at full size) so they don’t pixelate on a big poster or screen. If you plan to annotate further (say, put stickers or write on the board during trial), have an extra clean print in case you want one unmarked for evidence. Small extras like an easel, laser pointer, or light pen for the monitor can make the presentation smoother.

Conclusion

In a personal injury trial over spine surgeries, compelling medical illustrations can make the difference between jurors hearing about an injury and truly understanding and feeling it. Whether you commission a top-notch medical illustrator or create visuals in-house with software and stock images, focus on accuracy, clarity, and emotional impact. Illustrate the a disc replacement and microdiscectomy in a way that highlights the seriousness of the injuries and the life-altering nature of the surgeries. Combine these illustrations with the real MRI/X-ray evidence for maximum credibility – let jurors see the truth with their own eyes, then appreciate it with the expert’s guidance.

Finally, present these visuals thoughtfully in court: big, bold, and simple is better than convoluted or cluttered. Guide the jury through each image with clear testimony. A well-presented medical illustration can create that “eureka moment” when the light bulb goes off for a juror​

ckflaw.com, and they fully grasp what your client went through. That understanding, paired with an emotional connection, is key to persuading them toward a verdict that recognizes your client’s pain and suffering.

Sources:

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

More posts